Skip to content
Article

Is Direct Primary Care Worth Paying For If You Already Have Insurance?

Nada Farooqui, M.D.6 min read

It's the first question almost everyone asks me, and it's a fair one. You already pay a premium every month. Why would you pay again for a doctor?

Here's my honest answer, including the parts where direct primary care isn't the right fit. This one is written for people who already have coverage — if you don't have insurance at all, I've written about that separately.

What your insurance is actually good at

Insurance is built for the things that would otherwise ruin you financially. A hospital admission. Surgery. A cancer diagnosis. An ambulance ride and three days in the ICU. Those events are rare, enormously expensive, and impossible to budget for — which is exactly what insurance exists to handle.

I am not going to tell you to drop your coverage, and I don't want you to. Keep it. Direct primary care works alongside your insurance. It does not replace it.

What it was never built for

Primary care is the opposite kind of problem. It's frequent, relatively inexpensive, and it depends almost entirely on whether someone knows you and has time for you.

Running that through an insurance system adds cost and friction without adding much value. It's why a visit gets squeezed to seven minutes, why you're asked to come back for your second concern, why you see whoever is available instead of your own doctor, and why a bill shows up six weeks later for an amount nobody could have told you in advance.

None of that is a failure of the people working in it. It's what happens when you route everyday care through a system designed for catastrophes.

The math most people haven't done

Here's the part that changes the conversation.

If you have a high-deductible plan — and more of us do every year — you are already paying the full price of primary care out of pocket until you meet that deductible. Most people never meet it.

Say your deductible is $5,000. You see a doctor four times this year for ordinary things: a sinus infection, a blood pressure check, a physical, and something that worried you at 11pm. You pay for all four of those visits yourself. And you pay your premium every month on top of it.

“So the honest version of "I already have insurance" is often "I already pay a premium for something that doesn't cover the care I actually use."”

That's not an argument against having insurance. It's an argument for noticing what it's doing and what it isn't.

What changes when you pair them

With a Rawq Medicine membership, your primary care comes out of the insurance system entirely:

  • One flat monthly rate. You know the number before the month starts.
  • Visits that run 30 to 60 minutes, with time for everything on your list.
  • Direct access to me by text or call, without a phone tree in between.
  • Video visits when you can't get away from work or childcare falls through.
  • No copays and no surprise bills for your visits.
  • Labs and medications arranged at cost, which is often a fraction of retail.

Your insurance stays exactly where it belongs: covering the hospital, the specialist, the imaging, the emergency.

Something that changed this year

As of January 1, 2026, federal law settled a question that had been murky for years. Direct primary care membership fees are now a qualified medical expense, which means you can pay for them with HSA dollars. And enrolling in direct primary care no longer disqualifies you from contributing to your HSA, even when it's paired with a high-deductible plan.

In practice, that means a high-deductible plan, an HSA, and a direct primary care membership now fit together cleanly and intentionally — and your membership can be paid with pre-tax money. If your coverage comes through work, it is also worth a conversation there: you can ask your employer about direct primary care as a benefit.

There are monthly thresholds attached to that eligibility, and tax rules are not my area. Confirm the details with your accountant or benefits adviser.

When this isn't worth it

I'd rather tell you this now than have you join and feel misled.

If you're healthy, see a doctor once every few years, and nothing is bothering you, you may not get your money's worth. That's a reasonable conclusion and I won't argue with it.

If you're on Medicare, I'm not able to enroll you at this time. There's a waitlist, and I'll reach out if that changes.

And if what you want is someone to manage a hospital stay or handle a surgical problem, that's not what this is.

If you're choosing a plan right now

New Jersey's open enrollment runs November 1 through January 31, one of the longest windows in the country. If you want coverage starting January 1, you'll need to enroll earlier than the final deadline — check Get Covered New Jersey for the exact date.

I want to be clear about something: I am not an insurance broker, and I'm not going to tell you which plan to buy. That's a conversation for a licensed broker who can look at your actual situation.

What I will say is that this is the one month a year when the pieces are actually on the table in front of you, and it's worth understanding how they fit together before you pick. More people are choosing a lower-premium plan for the catastrophic risk and handling everyday care directly. Whether that's right for you depends on facts I don't know.

So — is it worth it?

The money question has a money answer, and for a lot of people it comes out even or better once you account for what you're already paying out of pocket.

But that's not really why people join.

They join because they're tired of explaining their history to someone new every time. Because they have a question at 9pm and nowhere reasonable to put it. Because the last three times they brought something up, they were told their labs were normal and sent home still not feeling right.

What you're paying for is time, and a doctor who knows you. Whether that's worth $150 a month is a question only you can answer — but you should at least get to answer it knowingly.

If you want to talk it through: I offer a free 15-minute discovery call. No commitment and no pitch. I'll tell you honestly whether I think this makes sense for your situation, including if the answer is no.

Dr. Nada Farooqui is a board-certified family physician and the founder of Rawq Medicine, a direct primary care practice in Hillsborough, New Jersey.

Portrait of Dr. Nada Farooqui, MD
Written by

Dr. Nada Farooqui, MD

Board Certified Family Medicine · Rawq Medicine, Hillsborough NJ. A Direct Primary Care practice — a flat monthly fee, no insurance in between, and time enough to explain things properly.

Ready for a doctor who has time for you?

Enrollment is open at Rawq Medicine in Hillsborough. Signing up online takes a few minutes.

HSA-eligible membership · No co-pays · No long-term contracts